Biancarosa, Gina. "After Third Grade." Educational Leadership, vol. 63, no. 2, Oct. 2005, pp. 16–22.
The author, Biancarosa, whittles down Reading Next, a paper she wrote in 2004 with Catherine Snow, on behalf of the Carnegie Corporation, condenses Reading Next, a 2004 report she co-wrote with Catherine Snow for the Carnegie Corporation, into a piece more digestible by, and useful to, front-line educators. She begins by positing that adolescent reading is not something that simply improves on its own; she shows that struggles continue, and are not caused by a single issue, which makes their cure complicated and multi-faceted. The report sets out nine instructional elements (methods and modalities of reading and writing), and six structural elements (aspects of classroom, schedule, and faculty) to be used as “ingredients” to a fuller literacy “meal”, rather than a menu from which a single item can be selected.
For our study group's question about activating prior knowledge, I saw explicit strategy instruction (teachers modeling strategies such as calling on prior knowledge and explaining when and why to use it before gradually withdrawing support), and the motivation element, (providing students a view of themselves as readers, affecting how much and how well they read) as being most key. Biancarosa asserts that teachers cannot bear alone the load of creating and sustaining adolescent literacy without school- and system-level structures supporting them. The article's biggest deficit is that it describes students as "struggling readers," a deficit-based label that later studies, including Hattan and Lupo's, push against.
"Episode 1: Why High Quality Lesson Study?" Making Mathematics Equity Concrete, California Action Network for Mathematics Excellence and Equity (CANMEE), 13 Aug. 2020. Apple Podcasts, podcasts.apple.com/jp/podcast/making-mathematics-equity-concrete/id1527083320.
In this first episode of CANMEE's podcast, three sixth-grade teachers, Amy Wirth, Christina Quiroga, and Anna Hunt, talk about their first cycles engaged in lesson study. The model discussed kept an equal focus on mathematics and equity. One team was cross-content (math, science, and ELA) and met every week for more than two months. The other team was, more similar to my teaching situation, a same-grade co-teaching partnership with a supportive principal. Both groups got to know focal students, and wrote strength-based descriptions that caught things not seen in test scores. After this preparatory work, they created equity-based research themes that formed concrete actions.
Until I heard this podcast episode, I hadn’t a good grasp of how lesson study worked. From it I gathered the following tips: choose low-floor, high-ceiling tasks; anticipate likely student solutions and follow-up questions; practice the lesson in front of peers before taking to the classroom. The observers, during the lesson, tracked a single focal student instead of the teacher, which gave better information on how the lesson went, and was less stressful for the teacher in front of the class. Varied solutions occurred to the lesson study group rather quickly, and the teachers found that the changes they made were lasting, including this new habit of collaboration and consideration of student impact prior to teaching a lesson. I do wish there had been a humanities angle as well…
Haberman, Martin. "The Pedagogy of Poverty Versus Good Teaching." Phi Delta Kappan, vol. 92, no. 2, Oct. 2010, pp. 81–87. Originally published in Phi Delta Kappan, vol. 73, no. 4, Dec. 1991, pp. 290–94.
The author of this paper, Martin Haberman, taught for years in urban classrooms, and from this experience, was able to define a set of education actions that make up what he calls the pedagogy of poverty: giving information, asking questions, assigning and monitoring seatwork, testing, settling disputes, and punishing noncompliance. He posits that this educational style has become what students, parents, administrators, and the public expect from low-income schools, despite lack of any academic support. Furthermore, he explains that these actions have no educational benefit. He explains why this style of non-education is so hard to eradicate via four egregious false reasonings.
Haberman goes on to say that good teaching can be seen in watching what students are doing rather than what the teacher is doing. Good teaching exists where students engage with issues important to them, revel in humanities diferences, help to create their own lessons, are encouraged to live their ideas (such as fairness), engage in philosophy, and are allowed and encouraged to revise their own work. He sees change happening on the school level, rather than that of single teachers. He also points out that change is pushed against by everyone from students to parents and administration.
Hattan, Courtney, and Daniel L. Dinsmore. "Examining Elementary Students' Purposeful and Ancillary Prior Knowledge Activation When Reading Grade-Level Texts." Reading Horizons: A Journal of Literacy and Language Arts, vol. 58, no. 2, 2019, pp. 24–47, scholarworks.wmich.edu/reading_horizons/vol58/iss2/3.
Hattan and Dinsmore looked at 25 third graders and 27 fifth graders in a southern urban district and gauged how they used prior knowledge while reading, without being prompted. The authors discussed two kinds of activation: purposeful (a reader deliberately calling up what they know as the immediate goal), and ancillary (a reader calls on knowledge indirectly to fill gaps, form an opinion, or question the author). While comparisons showed no major differences between the two statistically between grade levels or texts, they did find differences between reader profiles. The authors hypothesize the following: deliberate, purposeful activation may be a stage readers pass through before drawing on knowledge becomes automatic and an integral part of their reading, just like crawling comes before walking.
Hattan, Courtney, and Sarah M. Lupo. "Rethinking the Role of Knowledge in the Literacy Classroom." Reading Research Quarterly, vol. 55, no. S1, 2020, pp. S283–98, https://doi.org/10.1002/rrq.350.
Researchers Hattan and Lupo agree that knowledge is key to reading comprehension, but they argue that the idea of a "knowledge gap" applies a much to narrow scope to the idea of “knowledge,” giving students from nondominant communities a built-in handicap. They gave a sociocultural lens to the question of whose knowledge matters, explaining the following three tensions: Teachers who do not treat their students’ knowledge as important or worthy; knowledge activation not being spread out through periods before, during, and after reading, as well as when integrating new information and revising earlier ideas; content knowledge being thought of as the most important, or only, type of knowledge readers need. They believe that conditional knowledge, knowing when, how, and why to use what one knows, is crucial to student independence. The authors suggest techniques, including relational reasoning prompts (asking how a text is similar to or different from what students already know), and discussion-based K-W-L charts (in place of individually written ones).
Hinnant-Crawford, Brandi Nicole. Improvement Science in Education: A Primer. Myers Education Press, 2020.
This primer by Hinnant-Crawford is an introduction to improvement science for educators. Improvement science is a methodology that grew out of manufacturing, engineering, and health care, which puts the main purpose of any improvement firmly in the realm of equity and justice. The piece is for educators who want research to inform their teaching practice, and organizes its methodology around three questions: what exact problem am I trying to solve, what change might I introduce and why, and how will I know the change is an improvement. Our reading, Chapter 8, then works through the Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA) cycle, tracing its history from Shewhart and Deming and comparing it to the scientific method. The author stresses five features that make a PDSA cycle genuine (iteration, predictions, small-scale tests, data collected over time, and documentation) and notes that few published studies claiming to use PDSA include all five.
Chapter 8 offers concrete advice for teams just beginning this process, giving the following steps: Pair academic expertise with people with context and community experience; always ask whose voices are missing; write a charter that states aims, measures, scope, and threshold for doing no harm. Every phase of the cycle should be described in order, with the Act phase resulting in a decision to adopt, adapt, expand, abandon, or retest the studied change.The author makes a strong case for piloting a change with one class first. Her inclusion of qualitative documentation, such as journals and observation notes, also gives classroom teachers a way to treat everyday reflection as disciplined inquiry.
Jones, Fredric H. Tools for Teaching: Discipline, Instruction, Motivation. 2nd ed., Fredric H. Jones & Associates, 2007.
Jones’s classroom management system is built on the principle that prevention is far less costly than repair. He organizes it around the interconnected arenas of discipline, instruction, and motivation can stem from how a classroom is arranged and run. Early chapters focus on room arrangement and on the teacher moving continually among students so that physical proximity does much of the managing. His instructional methods include Say, See, Do, and Praise, Prompt, and Leave, a way of helping a stuck student that builds independence rather than dependence on instructors.
Lewis, Catherine C., and Jacqueline Hurd. Lesson Study Step by Step: How Teacher Learning Communities Improve Instruction. Heinemann, 2011.
Lewis and Hurd give educators a practical guide to lesson study, the Japanese framework and practice by which teachers plan a lesson together, teach it while colleagues observe students, and study what happened. Chapter 1 argues that lesson study is professional learning led by teachers rather than a seminar delivered to them. It contrasts how U.S. teachers tend to spend their improvement time, planning alone and aligning curricula to standards, with how Japanese teachers spend theirs, watching and discussing one another's lessons, the goal being not a polished lesson but the knowledge, dispositions, relationships, and access to one another's classrooms that teachers need in order to improve. They cite research linking teacher retention more closely to a collegial workplace than to salary.
In chapter 6 we read what teachers can expect from the process. Quoted teachers say that lesson study challenges them intellectually, and changes the first question they ask when planning, from what they will cover to what students should learn. This is one of my favorite take-aways from this whole trimester!
Svrcek, Natalie Sue, and Marium Abugasea Heidt. "Beyond Levels and Labels: Applying Self-Determination Theory to Support Readers." Literacy, vol. 56, no. 4, Oct. 2022, pp. 311–26.
Svrcek and Abugasea Heidt argue that defined reading levels, originally a tool for matching students to instructional texts, have hardened into labels that shape how children see themselves as readers and limit what they are allowed to read. As a reader and literature teacher, this kind of limitation horrifies me. In place of applying pre-determined levels to student readers, they apply self-determination theory, which holds that people are most motivated when three needs are met: autonomy, a sense of choice and ownership; competence, the feeling of being able to meet a real challenge; and relatedness, belonging to a community. When teachers meet those needs, the authors argue, students' reading motivation shifts away from rewards and avoiding punishment and toward reading for its own sake.
Most of the article is organized as three tables of classroom strategies, one for each need. For autonomy, these include genuine book choice, audiobooks offered to everyone rather than only as an accommodation, and ways to respond to reading beyond the essay. For competence, they include deliberately mixing easier and harder texts, one-on-one conferring, and organizing classroom libraries by topic or genre instead of by level. For relatedness, they include student-chosen book clubs, peer recommendations, and interest inventories.
Murata, Aki. “Introduction: Conceptual Overview of Lesson Study.” Lesson Study Research and Practice in Mathematics Education, edited by Lynn C. Hart et al., Springer, 2011, pp. xx–xx. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-90-481-9941-9_1.
Unfortunately, I have not yet read the entirety of the book noted above, but did read the Introduction, and from it have taken a quote I use in my Lesson Study The First.