Problem of Practice:
Our group now has three versions of Our PoP listed in our shared document. I have picked the second from this list, as it resonates most with me, though all three are similar:
How can we leverage routines around scaffolds to foster independence so we can lay the foundation for deeper thinking?
How can we activate prior knowledge in our students to support them in the process of beginning tasks independently?
How can we build consistent routines for using scaffolds so students become more independent and ready for deeper thinking?
I note all three here as it seems somehow worthy of mental chewing that after a month or so, things have gotten a little less defined than they were in the beginning. I am imagining this as analogous to the mess that a room becomes when tidying is being attempted: everything inside 5 human brains has to come out and be shuffled and sorted together before it can look neater.
In the first paper I will cover, the one we read as a group, Biancarosa (2005) summarizes Reading Next, which is a report by a national panel of researchers of academic literacy. The report identifies nine instructional elements and six structural elements for improving reading and writing in grades four through twelve. Since readers in upper grades struggle in very different ways, Biancarosa presents the elements given as “a list of ingredients (p. 21) to be combined for each context, not a menu from which to pick and choose only one or two.
Three elements from this paper bear most directly on our problem of practice. Direct, explicit comprehension instruction is the first: teachers need to model strategies such as summarizing and calling on prior knowledge, explain when and why to use each one, and gradually withdraw their support until students use these strategies independently.
The second element is motivation and self-directed learning. Older students’ views of themselves as a reader predict how much they read and how well they comprehend what they read, yet students’ sense of competence in reading and writing tends to decline as they progress through their school years. It is important that instruction offers choice, invites students to set their own goals, and provides feedback on progress, as these things have been found to strengthen students’ motivation and sense of competence.
Text-based collaborative learning is the third element that is key to coaching students into being successful readers. Discussing texts in mixed-ability groups will push students to confront their preconceptions and get them in the habit of supporting claims with evidence.
The text I read on my own saw Hattan and Lupo (2020) agreeing that prior knowledge is central to reading comprehension. However, they argue that current “knowledge gap” rhetoric too narrowly defines what knowledge is, and positions students from non-dominant backgrounds as deficient. The authors draw on both cognitive and sociocultural research around the question of whose knowledge matters, and they make three recommendations.
First, they suggest that teachers should treat students’ funds of knowledge (whether these resources students bring from home and community are cultural, linguistic, or experiential) as assets. Students notice when teachers doubt them, and that doubt reduces what they learn from texts.
Second, they remind us that knowledge activation does not reliably happen on its own. It should continue before, during and after reading, as well as alongside the intake of new ideas and the revising of old ones. Some ways to teach this habit are more effective than others, they note. For example, discussion-based Know-Wonder (or Want to Know)-Learned charts outperformed individually written ones in a study of ninth grade students (Lupo et al., 2019, as cited in Hattan & Lupo, 2020). Another successful method is relational reasoning prompts which ask students how a text is similar to, different from, or opposite to what they already know.
Finally, they remind us that content knowledge is only one of several kinds of knowledge needed by readers of any age. One that is often left out is conditional knowledge: knowing when, how, and why to use what one knows.
Before reading these articles, I thought of student/classroom/instructional independence as what remains once scaffolds are removed. Reading and comparing them changed that view. I now lean more toward the idea that independence is students’ growing judgement about when and how to draw on what they already know, as well as when and from where/whom to request assistance or input. Furthermore, I now think that judgement develops only in classrooms that treat students’ knowledge as worth using. Each of the articles supplies half of these arguments, and neither is complete without the other.
Biancarosa (2005) provides the instructional framework. Her description of explicit comprehension instruction essentially illustrates the gradual release of responsibility: the teacher models a strategy, explains why and when the student should use it, and then pulls back support as students show progress and success at that strategy. This framework describes how we hope students will learn to begin tasks on their own, the desired result of our PoP. However, it treats “calling on prior knowledge” (p. 17) as just one strategy among many at the start of reading, and Biancarosa does not address when or how often it should be activated.
Hattan and Lupo (2020) fill that gap and explain why that is not enough. They argue that activation is not a warm-up, but rather an ongoing process, and many students cannot do it unprompted no matter how much knowledge they possess. They also name a kind of knowledge that closely resembles Biancarosa’s emphasis on knowing “why they should use particular strategies in particular situations” (p.17): conditional knowledge, or knowing when, how, and why to use what one knows. Putting the two articles together, I would argue that conditional knowledge is where gradual release should lead when it comes to activation of prior knowledge. The goal is not simply that students can activate prior knowledge when prompted, but that they become able to recognize when and how to do it without being prompted.
The articles align on discussion. Biancarosa (2005) argues that collaborative learning helps students to wrestle with their preconceptions about the ideas coming from their peers and the things they read. Hattan and Lupo (2020) cite evidence that student activation through discussion works better than activation through solitary writing. For a ninth-grade classroom like mine, this suggests that the opening of a session might be better spent talking than by writing alone, at least until a routine becomes familiar enough for students to run it themselves. For example, a relational reasoning question regarding a recently covered piece ("What does this remind you of, and where does it not fit?") could first be posed to the whole class, then handed to partners on a prompt card, and eventually become a move students make on their own when starting a new text.
The largest point of friction between the two articles is how they frame students. Biancarosa (2005) organizes her argument around “struggling readers” (p. 18), while Hattan and Lupo (2020) warn that deficit labels shape what teachers expect, and therefore what students learn. This matters for our PoP because gradual release depends on a teacher’s judgement about who is ready for less support. If that judgement rests on assumptions about what students lack, support may be withdrawn from students who were never invited to use what they bring. Biancarosa’s own point about motivation supports this concern: she notes that students’ self-image as readers predicts how much they read and comprehend. Having a routine that positions students as knowers may build the exact confidence and competence that makes independent starting possible.
For our lesson study, this suggests designing the first minute of a task around a consistent activation move that students eventually run themselves. I am not sure whether that will take the form of a relational reasoning question about the current reading prior to writing, or something else. Ultimately, I think we see ourselves adding these habits, perhaps in the form of an initially expanding and then internalized habit checklist.
References
Biancarosa, G. (2005). After third grade. Educational Leadership, 63(2), 16–22.
Hattan, C., & Lupo, S. M. (2020). Rethinking the role of knowledge in the literacy classroom. Reading Research Quarterly, 55(S1), S283–S298. https://doi.org/10.1002/rrq.350