The reading I did for our group’s POP - “ How can we activate prior knowledge in our students to support them in the process of beginning tasks independently?” - really hammered home the idea that a teacher’s activation “moves” start purposefully: very explicit, and announced, of course, for the sake of the students, but also, in the case of “baby” teachers, for the sake of their own committing it to their tool-belt for future easy recall. The hope is that, with enough repetition, these activation routines will become automatic, and will not need announcing by the teacher for them to become something that students simply know to do in certain situations, which is really what “beginning tasks independently” means.
The activation of prior knowledge is not a single skill that students have or do not have; it is a habit that starts as a teacher-led scaffold of sorts. When it is done consistently, it becomes something students will do on their own without noticing. This idea shows up both in the article by Hattan & Dinsmore and my interview with Juli Ruff, who is currently a 9th grade teacher at High Tech High Point Loma in San Diego, California.
Hattan and Dinsmore (2019) cover this process explicitly, framing it as a "crawl before walking" process. The study covered by the paper, which took as its subjects, mid-to upper-grade elementary school students, split those students into reader “types” based on how they read. One type, referred to as “effortful processors”, were students who worked hard at reading, and pushed through whatever text they were given, asking themselves questions, making inferences, and filling in gaps with the results, but without ever stopping to say out loud, “this reminds me of…” In other words, they were not making known to people around them what their connections might be to prior knowledge of the subject matter; they just quietly used it, on task, to make sense of their reading.
The kids who utilized their own prior knowledge in this way, who self-activated it, did better on the comprehension questions afterward. The students who stopped, named and spoke explicitly about the connections they found were thought, perhaps, to be doing so as part of the development of their ability to activate prior knowledge, but the study couldn’t say this with complete certainty. They theorized that the out-loud kind of activation is a scaffold used by readers when the skill is still forming - the “crawl before walking” analogy - and, then, once the muscle is built, their announcements of connections stops being necessary, and becomes more of a silent, built-in part of how they read. This viewpoint holds that a student who is still narrating out loud is not worse off, but are rather earlier on in the learning-to-read process. Their study, however, was a snapshot, so the authors acknowledge that there is no proof, at least within their study, that their hypothesized “loud and purposeful to quiet and ancillary” progression theory is correct; they didn’t observe it directly.
Hattan and Dinsmore also wondered about another kind of reader that they flagged: the kind that showed almost no activation of prior knowledge at all. They referred to these students as “nonstrategic” readers; they were unsure if they were good test takers who didn’t lean on comprehension strategies like prior-knowledge activation much at all, or if they were simply kids who were not very verbal during a think-aloud. They were unsure, in the end, if this was a strength (invisible fluency) or a gap (not activating knowledge at all).
Juli aimed for the kids to take whatever activation skills she gave them, via habitual questions or scaffolding, and make them a study habit. She believes in “same moves, different topic or content” (personal communication, September 19, 2026) as a teaching tool: a routine repeated so often that it becomes transferable; in this, she is in line with the paper. She also reframed the idea of “guessing” (which she later clarified to not be random pointing but inference from prior knowledge, or even recently acquired knowledge) as being inference-making, which she sees as a legitimate, ordinary and welcome act rather than something only certain students get to do. In fact, she said that students who watch their peers constantly proffer answers think that these students know more, when really they are often simply better at activating and connecting prior knowledge and making inferences.
One place where Juli and the study authors differ is in dealing with stuck students. Juli’s method is to get their hands moving: get them writing, and then look at what they have created. The answer as to whether their gap is in content knowledge or strategy knowledge will, she says, appear early on in what they write. Since her philosophy on writing in her classroom is that first drafts are always “crap,” and that revisions do not detract from final grades, this is an understandable tack to take. The article’s case study data also shows that this might be the wisest move: trying to determine *why* a student is stuck before they even start writing may be a misuse of time and effort.
So, if the goal is to lead a student in shifting from purposeful and verbal to ancillary and quiet activation of prior knowledge, how do we actually notice when this shift happens for a student in our classroom? In a high school, where there is less vocal prompting during writing sessions, what would the equivalent be of watching for the kid who stops needing the “what do you know about…” prompt? I figure that we could continue to offer scaffolds, and notice who does and doesn’t use them, but will that constant offer of a ramp be tempting for those who can use the stairs already? I can see this being a beneficial lens, if not a subject altogether, for our group’s next PDSA cycle.
I am going to start storing up activation strategies - questions, thought processes, etc. - to use with my students to make sure that they are able to activate prior knowledge everywhere in their lives. I see it as the cornerstone of both curiosity and understanding, and believe that, as humans, we are a pattern-matching species, capable of mastering this skill.
References
Hattan, C., & Dinsmore, D. L. (2019). Examining elementary students' purposeful and ancillary prior knowledge activation when reading grade-level texts. *Reading Horizons: A Journal of Literacy and Language Arts, 58*(2), 24–47.