This year we are learning how to utilize lesson studies as a method of continuing education and professional development as teachers. I was excited to get started, and am thrilled to have this tool in my belt, as well as peers with whom to implement it. The idea of lesson study, described by one researcher as “a collaboration-based teacher professional development approach that originated in Japan” (Murata, 2011, p. 1), reminded me of the "blameless" postmortems, sprint retrospectives, and even mob programming from my previous career. I consistently learned more and became a better programmer when I was part of a development environment that built into its system time for us to create alongside our teammates, share code, and bug hunt together. We would often be on impromptu Slack chats during which we would be given the expectations for a project, ask what I now call "clarifying questions" under the motto "seek first to understand," and then share the brainstorming and troubleshooting. Once I got past my fear of failure being witnessed, I became eager to try this type of workflow with teaching. I initially had that same fear with my programming peers, many of whom are true geniuses; it is hard to be that open with people, but trust is key in any kind of group learning, another vital lesson I have learned (again) from this first lesson study course.
It may, perhaps, be an interesting aside to mention that the Japanese term for "lesson study" is jugyō kenkyū (授業研究), where jyugyou means “lesson/class” and kenkyuu means “study,” but with a “research” bent. Keeping this "reasearch" meaning in mind helps anchor the idea of lesson study to the realm of research and inquiry, rather than shared lesson planning or simple judgement.
My absolute favorite part of my first-ever lesson study was trying to come up with the essential question. It became clear, as we planned, how important the specifics of the question were. Here is the field from our team form that contains all the iterations and offshoots of our "Equity-based Research Question and Rationale" as they evolved:
How can we leverage routines around scaffolds to foster independence so we can lay the foundation for deeper thinking?
How can we activate prior knowledge in our students to support them in the process of beginning tasks independently?
How can we build consistent routines for using scaffolds so students become more independent and ready for deeper thinking?
Inquiry-based: If we use scaffolds in a consistent, predictable way, will students grow more independent and better prepared for deeper thinking?
Prior knowledge skills based on content-based prior knowledge
What do I already know to help me get started
Student: What tools and strategies do I need to get students started on their own and then to activate independence and agency in work to want to go deeper?
Teacher: what tools and strategies do I need to get my students started on their own to become more independent eventually foster deeper thinking
Consistent routines
Prior knowledge
Behavior
What tools and strategies support students to begin work independently?
Paired with these questions, we had our "Problem of Practice and Rationale":
We are not properly supporting students in getting started on work independently. Students ask a lot of questions about basic instructions and do not know how to use the scaffolds we are providing. We may be able to fix this by activating prior knowledge, using checklists, and providing better routines.
We are not teaching in a way that promotes student motivation or ability to think deeply about questions, prompts, and subjects we are providing. Students have stated they do not care about different perspectives or that they do not understand the purpose behind them. We may be able to fix this by activating prior knowledge and connecting our lessons to their experiences. With better routines, they may also be able to use more of their energy on deeper thinking and less on understanding instructions.
Brave Sam was our teaching team member, and we couldn't have had a better example to watch. If anyone ever wants to hear me gush about someone I want to be like when I grow up, please ask about this lesson study, and you will have to tell me when to stop. Her lesson for her 9th grade class was to be "Odysseus’ Hero Traits: The Last Chapter." We worked toward that day with the following checklist:
Create a checklist for a MEASURABLE in-class task (e.g., Starting a poster, working through an assignment, etc., and tracking students' completion (if possible also timestamps) - independent work
Strategies that promote independence are promoted routinely. Partner teaching (kids become experts and teach each other (jigsaw))
Strategies for promoting independence in writing (brainstorm, discuss, write)
Strategies around utilizing metacognition in order to have students become independent learners
Ways to classroom-manage in order for behavior to dissolve so students can begin
Provide sticky notes to students on steps to begin
The rest of my team also rolled out two PDSAs; I tried to as well, but I was working with a single student during this time period, and had limited success. The closest I came was a gradually whittled-down to-do list, that eventually dropped the list entirely and became an understanding. The deal we came to - that we would take a walk to feed crows after and only after the teacher was done talking and he'd done whatever warm-up started the class. Here is what I started with:
I am happy to say that the Crow Détente remains in place as a source of structure for my student, so I can't think of the gradually winnowing checklist as a failure.
The day of the lesson, we all ran from our teaching jobs to Poway, with this as our plan:
and this as our theory of action. You can see our actual plan document here.
Data collection is something I may have done well to consider before game day. I was clear on the kind of data we needed but hadn't given much thought at all to the actual mechanics of it. The classroom was smaller and more densely populated with tables, chairs, and students than I am used to, and I have to own that my body's fluffiness and my poor eyesight made keeping track of things harder than I'd thought. We did our best, however, and these are the pages of data we came away with:
(The last image is my attempt at taking part in the class bell-ringer activity, and I include it because it was fun, and to remind me to use it in my own class someday.)
In the end, we came to the conclusion that roughly 85 percent of students (25 of 29) in the class were able to initiate the task given when it was paired with what we presumed would become a routine scaffold/checklist. On the other hand, we noted that more than 2 of 3 questions were procedural, relating to the task and/or content of the assignment, with the rest revolving around their processing of the content itself, either linguistically or philosophically.
I look forward, with all sincerity, to my next lesson study, and I am far less afraid of being the teacher being observed. I see a tremendous amount of benefit, not only as a kind of continuing education, but also as a way to form trusting, open, generous academic communities. There are things I will keep from this first iteration:
It is crucial that we continue to make equity part of our overall goal.
Keeping the focus of the study small, something that can be implemented in a single class period, is also key. It took our Knowledgeable Other a good deal of gentle prodding to get us to pare down our initial, broad goals.
Finding and digesting topic-appropriate research set our foundation, and
Having a Knowledgeable Other kept us focused and reigned in.
Keeping in mind a selection of focus students made sure that we were able to implement a change fit for most, and with modifications for the rest.
Next attempts I think will include an earlier sharpening of the focal point of our essential question and problem(s) of practice, as well as more consideration given to actual mechanics.